Business Education

Manchester Business School Contact

Brexit Challenges | Alliance Manchester Business school  December 25, 2019 – 07:14 pm
Tbt what was our Business

Before the government enters into Brexit negotiations there needs to be an informed debate about the trade-offs involved, says Martin Walker, Professor of Finance and Accounting.

During the Brexit referendum, there was a heated debate about immigration. Sadly, the standard of the debate on this issue was extremely shallow, with ‘remainers’ often accused as being traitors to their country, and ‘brexiteers’ accused of being racist.

However, before our government enters into complex negotiations with the EU Involving a trade-off between restrictions on immigration and access to the single market, I think it is vital for the country to understand the issues involved. There needs to be an informed debate about the trade-offs involved.

Four key points need to be taken into account when thinking about this:

*Properly planned and controlled immigration can bring significant benefits to the UK economy as a whole.

*In particular, immigration from the EU countries appears to have contributed more fiscal benefits to the UK than immigration from outside the EU. This is demonstrated, for example, in a paper published in the Economic Journal in 2014 by Christian Dustmann and Tommaso Frattini which finds that “immigrants from the European Economic Area (EEA) have made a positive fiscal contribution, even during periods when the UK was running budget deficits, while non-EEA immigrants, not dissimilar to natives, have made a negative contribution”.

*The costs of immigration tend to be somewhat localised. So some parts of the country have to deal with the costs of immigration while other parts of the country enjoy the benefits whilst suffering few of the costs.

*To some extent, the costs of immigration are aggravated when the speed of immigration is unusually high. It becomes very difficult to plan housing, local services, health services, and the provision of school places in local areas experiencing very rapid increases in immigration.

Mitigating the costs

These four points have important implications both for managing the country and for managing our negotiations with the EU.

First of all the country has to find more intelligent ways of mitigating the costs of immigration. We need to put in place policies designed to ensure that local communities experiencing above average levels of immigration are not damaged.

This requires policies to, among other things, build more houses, increase school places, and improve local hospitals so as to accommodate increases in local populations.

Reasonable limits

Second, we need to explain to our partners in the EU that whilst we are willing to allow reasonable levels of immigration from the EU into the UK, there are reasonable limits on the speed of immigration that our economic and social systems can tolerate. There has to be some sort of emergency brake to limit the speed to immigration into the UK.

In addition, I would suggest that we should insist that any deal that we strike with the current members of the EU on this matter does not include any countries that might join the EU in the future. It would obviously be ludicrous to allow the EU to use the benefits of being allowed to work in the UK to attract new member states.


Canvas Zipper Pouch - Great Gift Choice - Organizes All Your Stuff! Makeup & Travel Items, Electronics & Car Keys, Fits 50 Pencils - Zipit All in This Fun Bag!
Office Product (Manchester Mercantile)
  • FUN & CONVENIENT way to keep your stuff together! Stop fumbling around in a briefcase, gym bag or tote for a specific item we need? End the madness~Simply set...
  • CATCHY PHRASE & WASHABLE NATURAL COTTON fabric bags, with no toxic plastic smell, make this useful pouch so appealing. If you have STUFF, then this organizer...
  • PROTECT YOUR EARBUDS and tech devices from crazy tangling by dropping them into this cell phone accessory bag for safe keeping. Keeps items from rolling around and...
  • PERFECT ZIPPERED CARRY ALL POUCHES for holding traveler toiletries, lip gloss & sunglasses, check books & credit cards, documents & passports when traveling...
  • GREAT PRESENT for Girlfriends, Teens, Birthdays, Mother s Day, Teacher Thank You Presents, Bridesmaids, Bridal Showers, Sorority EventsHow can you go wrong? Guaranteed...
Twins Enterprise/47 Brand International Soccer Manchester City 47 Clean Up Adjustable Visor, One Size, Navy
Sports (Twins Enterprise/47 Brand)
  • Support your favorite team in style & comfort
  • Classic look & feel - Great gift for fans!
  • 47 produces only the finest sportswear for the fashion-conscious fan
  • Officially Licensed product of the English Premier League
  • Check out all new 47 caps, knits, t-shirts, hoodies, pullovers, socks, scarves and more -- available for all your favorite teams!
New Hampshire State Necklace - IBD - Personalize with Name or Coordinates - Choose Chain Length - Pendant Size Options - Ships in 2 Business Days - Sterling Silver 14K Rose Gold Filled Charm
Guild Product ()
Manchester Mercantile Canvas Zipper Pouch - Santa's Favorite - Organizes Makeup and Travel Toiletries, Electronics and Car Keys, Fits 50 Pencils
Office Product (Manchester Mercantile)
  • THE ORGANIZE & STYLISH WAY to keep stuff zipped together! How many times do we find ourselves fumbling around in a purse, backpack or gym duffell for a specific...
  • CLASSIC PATTERN & NATURAL COTTON FABRIC ACCESSORY POUCHES, with no toxic plastic smell, make this organizer bag appealing to all of us. If you have STUFF, and...
  • PROTECT YOUR EARBUDS & battery cords from crazy tangling for safe keeping. No more knotted charger cords. Excellent packing organizer for your next adventure...
  • PERFECT INTERESTING FINDS Zippered Lightweight Pocket Tote When Traveling! For holding car keys & sunglasses, coupons & credit cards, office & desk supplies...
  • GREAT HOLIDAY GIFTING IDEA: Valentines Day, Mother s Day Teacher presents, Bridal showers, Sorority sisters~How can you go wrong? Your satisfaction is guaranteed...

Related posts:

  1. Manchester Business School Singapore
  2. Manchester Business School West
  3. Manchester Business School staff
  4. Manchester Business School Portal